Alwaysbrewingdetroit

Detroit news

Curbed Cup Elite Eight

Grandmont-Rosedale vs. West Village — A Battle for Detroit’s Soul

In 2012, Detroit’s neighborhoods weren’t just fighting for survival—they were battling for bragging rights. The Curbed Cup’s Elite Eight pitted Grandmont-Rosedale, a bastion of historic stability, against West Village, a scrappy arts enclave breathing new life into abandoned corners. With over 10,000 votes cast in earlier rounds, the question loomed: Would tradition triumph, or would reinvention reign? Let’s revisit the clash that divided Motor City loyalists.

The Contenders: Two Worlds, One City

Grandmont-Rosedale: Where Time Stands (Mostly) Still

Picture tree-lined streets where Tudor revivals and Craftsman bungalows whisper tales of Detroit’s mid-century heyday. Grandmont-Rosedale wasn’t just a neighborhood—it was a time capsule. In 2012, its community gardens and block clubs thrived, while the Rosedale Park Historic District stood as a monument to resilience. But critics called it “stubbornly retro” in a city desperate for change.

West Village: Detroit’s Phoenix Rising

Meanwhile, West Village buzzed with the chaotic energy of a DIY revival. Artists converted boarded-up storefronts into galleries. Coffee shops like Red Hook lured millennials with fair-trade lattes and loft dreams. The neighborhood’s crown jewel? The Pewabic Pottery Studio, a 110-year-old institution mixing heritage with hipster ceramics classes. But was this progress—or pandering to outsiders?

The Fight: Nostalgia vs. New Blood

Grandmont-Rosedale’s Case

  • Historic Cred: 95% of its homes retained original pre-WWII architecture (Detroit Historical Society, 2012).
  • Community Muscle: The Grandmont Rosedale Development Corporation rehabbed 50+ houses since 2008.
  • The Knock: “We’re not stuck in the past—we’re preserving a blueprint for urban success.”

West Village’s Counterpunch

  • Arts Boom: 15 new creative studios opened in 2012 alone (Metro Times).
  • Curb Appeal: Vacant lots became pop-up parks; murals masked blight.
  • The Dig: “You can’t eat history. Detroit needs now energy.”

Behind the Scenes: Dirty Tactics?

The rivalry wasn’t all porch swings and pottery wheels. Rumors swirled:

  • West Village fans accused Grandmont-Rosedale of busing in suburban retirees to vote.
  • Grandmont loyalists claimed West Village’s “artists” were just trust-fund squatters.
    The Detroit Free Press even joked: “This isn’t a neighborhood contest—it’s a generational cage match.”

The Verdict: Why This Battle Mattered

The Curbed Cup wasn’t just about trophies—it was a proxy war for Detroit’s identity. Did the city’s future lie in safeguarding its past, or rewriting its narrative?

  • Grandmont-Rosedale argued stability attracts families, rebuilds tax bases, and stops the bleed.
  • West Village bet on creativity as economic fuel, proving empty spaces could become engines.

In the end, the vote was razor-thin. West Village won by 2%, but the real victory? Proving Detroit’s heart beat in both its history and its hustle.

  • Detroit’s Coffee Scene

    Detroit’s Coffee Scene

    More Than a Caffeine Fix In 2010, Detroit had fewer than 20 specialty coffee shops. Today, that number has tripled—with over 60 cafés fueling the city’s caffeinated comeback. But this isn’t just about lattes; it’s about lattes as lifelines. How did Motor City’s coffee scene become a catalyst for community, creativity, and even conflict? We visited.